How the research works

Join Worthy records what a company did, what the record supports and what is still unknown, so you can reach your own judgment. Every finding links to a dated document version and the passage it rests on.

Seven lenses

Research is organized in seven independent lenses. Each company page lists the latest matters in every lens and says whether editors have reviewed it.

  • Product and business model
  • Privacy and data rights
  • Safety and responsible AI
  • Workers and labor
  • Climate and environment
  • Supply chain and communities
  • Governance and accountability
  • Not reviewed means no dated coverage review exists for that lens, even if some matters are published in it. It is a gap in our research, not a clean record.
  • Reviewed, nothing to publish means editors reviewed the lens on the date shown and found nothing to publish as of that date.
  • A recognized company with no published matter or review has no Ledger yet. That is missing research. A company we do not recognize has no page.

Kinds of finding

Every finding has one claim type. Types are never averaged or combined; only editors’ ratings of resolved matters feed the index.

Commitment
What the company says it does or will do. Not independently checked.
Allegation
A claim made against the company that has not been established.
Proceeding
A formal legal or regulatory process is under way.
Established outcome
A result established by an order, ruling, filing or direct observation.
Independent assessment
A review by a party independent of the company.
Unknown
The record does not yet show what happened. Not a negative finding.

Procedural status, such as alleged, filed or ordered, is shown separately. A settlement or order does not establish every earlier allegation.

Findings and matters

  • A finding is one claim, with the scope it covers. A company-level finding says nothing about a particular team unless the source supports it.
  • A matter groups the findings that tell one story over time, such as a commitment and the review that tested it. Matters are listed by the date of their latest finding, never by importance.
  • Counts are distinct records. A matter that counts in two lenses is counted once in the company totals.
  • A parent company and its subsidiaries are separate entities. Each Ledger and its counts cover one entity; the page links to the others without combining their evidence.

Sources and publication rights

Each passage shows its locator and the exact document version it comes from, so a later edition never silently replaces the one a finding relied on.

  • Kinds of source. Each source is labeled as an official record, a company publication, news reporting, research or another source, with its publisher.
  • Syndicated copies. A republished copy is marked as a copy of its original. It is counted as a document but not as an independent source.
  • Quotation rights. Each document version records whether it is restricted, citable without quotation, or quotable. A restricted document is never shown. Without recorded quotation rights the passage is cited by locator and version, and its text is withheld.
  • Provenance. Each document version states where it came from and the rights it was published under.

The Integrity Index

Editors rate each matter with a resolved outcome or independent assessment as adverse, favourable or context only, and how severe. A matter linked to several lenses has its points split between them. Each lens turns its ratings into a score from 0 to 100, each lens total is scaled down for company size, and the published index (version 1.0) is the average of lenses with a completed coverage review. It is withheld below 5 reviewed lenses. Allegations, pending cases and unverified commitments never move a score; they widen its range. A matter awaiting a rating counts in neither. How the index is calculated

Compensation

Pay figures are ranges companies published for specific roles, archived with their source. They are offers, not earnings. Total compensation counts only when base, bonus and equity are all stated, and only disclosures for the same role, level, country and currency are compared. How compensation data is collected

Corrections and withdrawals

A published correction creates a new version of the matter with a public reason; the matter keeps its address. A withdrawn matter keeps its address and the reason for withdrawal, not the withdrawn content. Drafts, staff identities and restricted audit records are never public.